Every year around tax season, we hear the same question from new clients: “Can’t I just use AI to do this?” It’s a fair question. AI tools have gotten genuinely impressive, and the promise of filing your taxes for free in a few minutes is obviously appealing.
But a new survey suggests that after a year of real-world experience, a lot of taxpayers are pulling back on that idea — and not by a small margin.
What the Data Actually Says
According to a February 2026 survey conducted for Invoice Home — covered by both the Journal of Accountancy and Accounting Today — trust in AI for tax filing dropped from 43% to 37% in a single year. That’s a meaningful shift in a short amount of time. And it’s not confined to one age group: comfort with AI for taxes declined across every generation surveyed.
Here’s the generational breakdown:
| Generation | Would trust AI (2025) | Would trust AI (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Gen Z | 49% | 46% |
| Millennials | 54% | 50% |
| Gen X | 43% | 40% |
| Baby Boomers | 25% | 24% |
| Silent Generation | 18% | 15% |
Across the board, the trend moved in the same direction. Even the generations most comfortable with technology are becoming less comfortable handing their taxes to an AI tool.
We’re Not Surprised — And Here’s Why
We want to be straightforward with you: we’re a CPA firm, so we’re obviously not a neutral party here. But the reason we’re not surprised by this data has nothing to do with protecting our business. It has to do with what taxes actually require.
Tom Hood, CPA, executive vice president at the Association of International Certified Professional Accountants, put it well when he said the real question isn’t “AI or CPA” — it’s who you want at the center of the relationship. His framing: a CPA using the latest technology as a trusted adviser is the answer most people actually want, whether they realize it or not.
That matches what we see every day. The clients who’ve tried AI tools before coming to us don’t come in because the AI gave them a wrong number (though that happens). They come in because they didn’t know what questions to ask. AI will answer what you ask. It won’t tell you what you forgot to ask.
The Confidence Gap Is Real
The survey surfaced something else that stood out to us: only 42% of respondents said they were confident they would file their taxes correctly this year. That number barely budged from 2025, when it was 41%.
For Gen Z and Millennials, it’s worse — only about a third of Gen Z respondents and 36% of Millennials expressed confidence in their own filings. And yet these are the groups most likely to try to go it alone, with AI or otherwise.
There’s a disconnect there. If you’re not confident in the outcome, the answer isn’t to use a faster tool — it’s to use a more reliable process.
What AI Is Actually Good At (And Where It Falls Short)
We use technology in our own work, so we’re not here to tell you AI is useless. It isn’t. For straightforward factual questions — “what’s the standard deduction this year?” or “when is the filing deadline?” — AI tools perform reasonably well.
But a NerdWallet analysis published in March 2026 tested three major AI chatbots on tax questions and found a consistent pattern: the tools got black-and-white answers right but became unreliable when questions required personalization, nuance, or legal interpretation. Answers to the same question varied between sessions. The tools made assumptions about the filer’s situation that weren’t always accurate.
Taxes are a math problem and a legal problem at the same time. AI has gotten better at the math. The legal and situational judgment — what elections to make, what deductions you qualify for, how your circumstances this year differ from last year — still requires a human who knows your file.
The Question We’d Ask You to Consider
The survey data shows that 63% of taxpayers already don’t trust AI over a tax professional. If you’re in the 37% still on the fence, that’s a legitimate place to be — and we’d rather you think it through than just take our word for it.
Ask yourself: Is my tax situation exactly the same as last year? Did anything change — income, investments, a home purchase, a new business, a dependent, a major expense? If the answer to any of those is yes, you’re in territory where an AI tool is going to answer what you ask and miss what you don’t.
That’s the part of the job that hasn’t changed, no matter how good the technology gets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it safe to use AI to file my taxes?
For very simple returns with no changes year over year, AI tools may produce accurate results. The risk increases with complexity — self-employment income, investment activity, life changes, or any situation that requires judgment about deductions and elections. A 2026 survey found 63% of taxpayers don’t trust AI over a tax professional for exactly this reason.
What can a CPA do that AI can’t?
A CPA asks questions you didn’t know to ask, identifies planning opportunities before they expire, and applies professional judgment to situations that don’t have a single correct answer. AI responds to what you input. A CPA looks at your full picture.
Is AI for taxes getting better or worse?
The technology is improving, but taxpayer trust in AI for tax filing actually declined from 2025 to 2026, dropping from 43% to 37% according to the Invoice Home survey. Real-world experience appears to be tempering early enthusiasm.
How much does it cost to hire a CPA for taxes?
Cost varies based on the complexity of your return, your business structure, and the services involved. The more relevant question is usually what it costs not to — in missed deductions, filing errors, or IRS notices that a professional would have prevented.
We’re Happy to Talk Through Your Situation
If you’re weighing your options for this tax season or planning ahead, we’re glad to have that conversation. There’s no commitment involved in a consultation — and you’ll leave knowing exactly what your situation calls for, whether that’s working with us or not.
🇺🇸 (713) 451-9700
🇨🇦 (416) 800-2709
Source: AI Loses Ground to Pros as Taxpayers Rethink Who Should Do Their Taxes, The Tax Adviser / Journal of Accountancy, February 2026.
